FFWPU Europe and Middle East: James Edgerly's Another Tragedy in Japan: The Targeting and Dissolution of the Family Federation

Another Tragedy in Japan: The Targeting and Dissolution of the Family Federation, is the title of a 40-page booklet moderated by James B. Edgerly and published by Higher Purpose Forum as a second edition in July 2025. The publication presents a deeply considered reflection on the legal and social pressures confronting the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification (FFWPU) James Edgerly, founder and - formerly the Unification Church - in Japan. Edgerly is founder director of the Higher Purpose and director of the Higher Purpose Forum, which according to him Forum. Screenshot from live is an “independent project of the Unification Movement”. transmission by HPF May 8, 2024 Edgerly dedicates the booklet to Toru Goto - a Unificationist who twice suffered abduction and forced confinement by his family, the second time for more than 12 years - from 1995 to 2008. After years of legal battle, he achieved a landmark Supreme Court victory in 2015. That court ruling did not end the coercive practices of dehumanizing faith-breaking entirely, but made it much more difficult for the professional

deprogrammers to market their shady services. Goto’s story serves as a testament to both the resilience of faith and the broader trajectory of rights for religious minorities in Japan.

Situational Context and Legal Background

Edgerly measures the recent dissolution order issued by a Tokyo court against a broader historical backdrop. In October 2023, Japan’s Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) filed a request to dissolve the Family Federation of Japan, citing allegations like “manipulative fundraising” and other civil violations. In March 2025, the Tokyo District Court granted that request - an unprecedented legal step against a religious organization that had no criminal convictions on record.

Edgerly contrasts Japan’s legal and cultural response with that of other democracies, particularly the United States, where religious freedom, including for unpopular movements, remains more vigorously safeguarded. He underscores that the civil cases cited by the court in Japan stem largely from decades-old disputes - all predating a 2009 compliance reform [See editor’s note below] - and that many plaintiffs are ex-members whose testimonies The reality of faith-breaking: originated from “deprogramming” conditions now considered Toru Goto, a member of the coercive and discredited. Family Federation, in 2008, barely able to move after being The Media, Law, and Public Sentiment held in forcible detention by his own family in league with One of the most striking elements in the booklet is the analysis of professional faith-breakers for two press conferences at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club of more than 12 years Japan (FCCJ), held just two days apart in March 2025. On 26th March, Federation President Tomihiro Tanaka calmly and factually responded to criticism - highlighting, for instance, the disappearance of complaints and civil cases over the past seven years, and the overwhelming origin of plaintiffs from deprogramming scenarios.

In contrast, on 28th March, representatives from anti- Unificationist lawyer networks (e.g., NNLASS) made sweeping claims, calling the Federation’s activities “fabrications” and labeling its ceremonies as forced mass weddings. Their tone was triumphalist and dismissive of Federation perspectives - but received applause from the press, underlining a broader media bias.

Tomihiro Tanaka, President of Edgerly argues that this polarized messaging - and the absence of the Family Federation in Japan, active Unificationist voices in the courtroom or investigative speaking at a press conference at processes - exemplifies a disturbing erosion of due process and the Foreign Correspondents’ fair representation. Club of Japan on the afternoon of 26th March 26, 2025 in Tokyo, Historical Campaign Against the Federation Japan Edgerly situates the recent legal attack within a five-phase historical arc spanning over five decades:

1981-2025 - Anti-Unification legal entities formed early, engaging in deprogramming referrals, lawsuits, and generating “manufactured victims” The so-called “Defection Business” grew into a significant civil litigation mechanism.

2009-2022 - The 2009 compliance measures [See editor’s note Tetsuya Yamagami, the suspect below] marked a pivotal reform. Meanwhile, the Toru Goto case for the assassination of Shinzo in 2015 reduced forced deprogramming significantly, setting a Abe, the former prime minister of precedent for religious freedom protections. Japan 2022-Present - The assassination of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe in July 2022 by Tetsuya Yamagami (who blamed the Federation for his family’s bankruptcy) triggered a national backlash. Anti-Unification lawyers quickly framed the Federation as culpable, shifting public anger towards institutional dissolution rather than focusing on the assassin himself.

From a conference by International Federation for Victory over Communism (IFVOC) in Japan 1972

Democratic and Human Rights Stakes

Edgerly warns that dissolving a religious organization without criminal violations - primarily based on civil claims and hostility - sets a dangerous precedent for Japan’s democratic ethos and for religious freedom globally. He notes how international bodies like the U.S. State Department, the U.N., and religious freedom advocates have raised alarm, emphasizing that such actions deviate from both Japan’s constitution and international obligations under instruments like the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).

He particularly highlights the lack of transparent dialogue, the “herd mentality” of media-fueled public sentiment, and the marginalization of the Family Federation’s narrative - all signaling a broader slide toward ideological conformity and against pluralism.

Edgerly’s booklet offers more than documentation; it is a care-filled plea for balance, justice, and empathy. This narrative:

Humanizes the believers - showcasing their victimization and the trauma of harassment, job loss, evictions, and social ostracism.

Elevates legal awareness by clearly showing that those bringing suit were beneficiaries of coercive methods, undermining the integrity of evidence.

Connects modern events to long-standing tradition of pluralistic suppression, reminding us that the tensions predate the Abe assassination.

Champions democratic resilience, highlighting voices - journalists, international advocates, and faith leaders - who reject the punitive dissolution order and stand for religious liberty.

In doing so, it challenges readers to consider whether a truly democratic society should retaliate against religious minorities through legal means based on prejudice rather than fair adjudication.

In Another Tragedy in Japan, James Edgerly provides a powerful, compassionate account of a religious community caught in the crossfire of decades-long ideological warfare, public outrage, and legal overreach. The booklet goes beyond chronicle - it is a call for empathy, justice, and vigilance. It affirms that democratic values and religious freedoms are fragile, especially when public pressure eclipses critical thinking and fair treatment.

Text: Knut Holdhus, editor

[Editor’s note: The 2009 compliance declaration of the Unification Church of Japan (now the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification) was a formal commitment by the organization to reform its practices in response to longstanding public criticism and legal challenges.

The Unification Church in Japan had faced numerous allegations related to recruitment tactics and donation solicitation, termed “spiritual sales” (霊感商法) by a hostile network of activist lawyers who had declared the religious organization an enemy. These issues led to multiple lawsuits orchestrated by the activist lawyers and significant media backlash. This prompted the organization to take measures to restore its reputation and demonstrate compliance with legal and ethical standards.

The religious organization pledged to stop possibly unethical donation practices, including what the hostile network of lawyers claimed amounted to “pressuring members into making large financial contributions under spiritual pretexts.”

This was in response to accusations from the same activist lawyers that followers “were being manipulated into giving away substantial amounts of money or property.”

The Unification Church stated it would enhance internal oversight to ensure compliance with ethical and legal standards. Measures included better training for leaders and stricter guidelines for evangelization and solicitation of donations.

After this compliance declaration, there was a significant decrease in the number of lawsuits against the Unification Church - since 2015 called the Family Federation. The religious organization has used this as evidence that it has improved its practices and should not be subject to dissolution.]

Related to new book on persecution in Japan: Japan Following the Way of China

Also related to new book on persecution in Japan: Media Stereotypes and Misinformation Challenged

Also related to new book on persecution in Japan: Media Criticized for Stereotyping Minorities

Also related to new book on persecution in Japan: After the N-Word: Is “Cult” Next Term to Be Banned?

Also related to new book on persecution in Japan: Japan’s Dissolution Case Echoes China’s Playbook

And also related to new book on persecution in Japan: “Lawyers Lying and Shaming Japan” for 50 Years

More, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Lawfare: State Uses Legal System in War on Faith

Also related to new book on persecution in Japan: Media/Legal Expert: Communism Behind Persecution

And more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Militant Lawyers Dictate Government Policy

And more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Media Helping Terrorist Reach His Goal

Related to new book on persecution in Japan: Kishida Administration Giving in to Terrorism

And more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: 12 Religious Freedom NGOs Denouncing Japan

Yet more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Japanese Communists’ Final War

Still more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Political and Social Activism behind Oppression

And yet more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Opposition Inciting Regime to Excessive Steps

And still more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Journalist Reveals Ugly Leftwing Conspiracy

And even more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Gingrich: Kishida Joining Communist Campaign

Yet more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: The 3 Enemies of Religious Liberty

Still more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Lawyer Exposes Dirty Leftwing Plot

And yet more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Inhuman Government-Supported Mass Deprogramming

And still more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Bias: No Right to Respond for Religious Minority

And even more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Collusion to Rob Minority of Its Rights

Yet more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: State and Media Creating “Today’s Non- Citizens”

Still more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Japan Criticized for Glaring Rights Violations

And yet more, related to new book on persecution in Japan: Two European Scholars Warning Japan

Yonhap: Repeated Alie < 11 >

RELIGIOUS FREEDOM T COMMEMORATING T

Apartment Prison: Faith- lilEIEIEI Share: El Breaking In Modern Japan • August 15, 2025: • Knut Holdhus

Japan: New Book On Legal And Social Attacks August 16, 2025

-- Yonhap: Repeated Allegations Create Public Bias August 14, 2025

Churches Urged To Repent For Dissolution Role August 13, 2025

UPI Bias: Does UPI- - -· Legal History Shape Reporting? August 12, 2025

Japan: Hidden History Of Coercive Faith- Breaking August ll, 2025

Interfaith Call New book: English version of one of ‘25 To Protect modern Japan’s most disturbing Religious Liberty August 10, 2025 human rights cases: The attempted faith-breaking of Toru Goto - locked up Experts Flag

for over 12 years in apartment turned t4•-U Flawed Case; Media Chooses Silence prison August 9, 2025

[Review] 4536 Days in Captivity Toru Goto’s Battle for Survival - 4536 Days in Captivity is both a Search … IEII survivor’s testimony and a meticu lously documented chronicle of one of modern Japan’s most d isturbing human rights cases: t h e abduction and Categories

prolonged confinement ot a man by his own family, under the guidance of professional “deprogrammers”, in an effort to force him to abandon his religious faith. Spanning twelve Send us a message years and five months of capt ivity- 4,536 days - fol lowed First Name * Last Name by seven years of lega l battle, Goto’s account is an unflinching examination of coercion, the Toru Coto went through 72 years corrosion of trust, and the a n d 5 months of forcible Email * resilience of belief under detention. Illustration: Japanese extreme pressure. Victims’ Association against Email Address Religious Kidnapping and Forced The book opens w ith the stark Conversion Your Message * image of photographs from cou rt records - d im rooms, c racked g lass, worn tatami -taken from the very apartment in central Tokyo w here Toru Goto (~iilffiS!) was h idden away for over a decade. This fram ing sets the tone: evidence /, and memory intertwined, each reinforcing t he rea lity of an ordeal t hat mig ht otherw ise seem unbelievable. The c rime, formally recognized Submit in Japanese courts, is not set in a distant war zon e or a remote prison, but in the midst of an ordinary city neighborhood.just minut es from a bust ling train station.

Goto begins by introducing his fami ly - respectable, educated, middle-class. His father, a successful corporate executive; his mother, a gentle and devoted homemaker; his siblings, capable and supportive. The warmth of his childhood - family outings to fish in Okutama, the comfort of his mother’s cooking - stands in tragic contrast t o what would come later. Th is contrast is deliberate: it challenges any easy assumpt ion that such extreme acts can only be committed by “bad” or obviously unstable people.

The turning point comes in the mid-1980s when Goto’s older brother encount ers t he Unification Church (now called the Family Federation) and introduces h im to it. Initia lly skeptica l, Goto finds in the church’s teach ings a sense of purpose and h ope t hat answers deep personal doubts. Within a year, all t h ree siblings are members, and for Goto, t he fait h becomes a central part of his life. But as membership grows nationally, so does opposition - from both theological rivals and political adversa ries, some of whom adopt the controversial practice of “deprogramming” through abduction and confinement.

W hat fo llows in Chapt er 1 is a gradual t ightening of the net. Goto’s brot her is the first to van ish, seized and confined under the direction of anti- Unification activists. Lat er, Got o h imself is lured by his fat her to what he bel ieves w il l be a meet ing, only to be locked in a “connecting room” at a luxury hot el and Illustration OfToru Goto being kidnapped in subjected t o verba l order to coercively break his faith. Image: National Association of Victims of assau lts from Abduction, Confinement, and Forced deprogram mer Deconversion Takashi Miyamura (‘g f’t~) and former believers. Though he eventually escapes, t he experience t eaches him that physical force is not the on ly danger - psychological pressure and isolation can be equally devastating.

The book’s middle sect ions describe t h e intricate network behind these deprogrammings: pastors, ex-members, and laypeople coordinating to coach famil ies on how to lure, rest rain, and “rehabil itate” relatives. Goto investigates t he history of these efforts, linking them to broader political movement s of the Cold War and to the media-f ueled moral panic over “new relig ions” in Japan. This is one of the book’s strengths: it is not simply memoir, but also a socio log ica l record of a part icula r moment in Japanese religious politics, w here anti-communist activism, theological d isputes, and sensat ionalist journalism converged to legitimize extraj udicial coercion.

The most harrowing part of the narrative begins in Sept ember 1995, when, after years of cautious contact w ith h is family, Goto is ;:::ihrl 11rt(:)rl ;::::iri::ain - th i~ timj::l, \Nith rn(:litirt 11(“)11~

planning and the c lear intent of p rolonged confinement. He is taken to an apartment in Niigata, its doors and windows secured w ith heavy locks, where his captors, including h is parents and sibli ngs, rotate to maintain constant watch. Here, professional deprogrammer Pastor Yasutomo Matsunaga Faith-breaker: pastor (t’i:i](.~~J beg ins a campaign of critic ism, Yasutomo ridicule, and theological challenge designed Matsunaga (/z,’7j(fifflfi’) to break Goto’s faith. of the Niitsu Evangelical Christian The conditions are psycholog ically punishing: Church. Photo: total isolation from news, friends, or any FFWPU outside contact; daily verbal assau lts; the manipulation of fam ily bonds to induce gu ilt. Former members are brought in to model “successf ul” depa rtures from the church. The aim is not merely intellectual persuasion but emotional exhaustion - an erosion of identity through relentless pressure. Goto, drawing on years of mental preparation and prayer, resolves to resist. His strategy is pragmatic: to feign doubt, endure the attacks, and wait for a genu ine chance to escape.

Through these pages, the reader feels the claustrophobia - not only the physical confinement but the narrowing of mental space under constant surveillance. Got o’s detailed descript ions of the apartment layouts, lock mechanisms, and routines emphasize how control is engineered down to the sma llest detail. His earlier experiences at the “Cat-dog apartment” and Ogikubo Glory Church had taught him that opportunity cou ld come unexpect edly- during a supervised outing, or in a moment when v ig ila nce lapses.

The narrative also fol lows the collateral damage: his younger sister’s abduction, his fiancee’s d isappearance into a similar “ rehabil itation” process, the complicity of police who d ismiss such incidents as “fami ly matters”. Each case reinforces a core theme -that the social and legal environment of the t ime allowed these abductions to continue largely unchecked.

Goto’s event ual release is not the end of the story. The fina l sections shift from surv iva l to legal and mora l vindication. He files civil and c riminal complaints, navigating a legal system often reluctant to confront the intersection of family autonomy and indivi dual rights. His v ictories in district and high courts, and the ultimate affirmat ion by the Supreme Court, are presented not as personal triumphs alone but as precedents for t he prot ection of religious freedom and personal liberty in Japan.

Protesting against the evil of deprogramming (faith-breaking) in Shinjuku, Tokyo 8th December 2024. Here, Toru Coto (!Jf iJfj fit}, representing the National Association of Victims of Abduction, Confinement, and Forced Religious De-Conversion (center}, delivering a speech. The posters behind him carry p ictures of Toru Coto hardly able to walk after more than 72 y ears of forcible confinement. Photo: Reiwa Kato (/Jll iJfj # fll)

The analysis that emerges from Goto’s account is layered. At one level, it is a study in endurance - the inner resources requ ired to survive long-term captivity w ithout capitu lating to psychologica l manipulation. At another, it is an expose of a quasi-organized system of coercive faith-breaking , involving relig ious leaders, lay operatives, and family members, operating in a grey zone tolerated by public opin ion and law enforcement. At yet another, it is a medit ation on the fragility of trust: how quickly shared history and affection can be weaponized when belief systems c lash.

Crucially , Got o resists casting h is family as one-dimensional v illains. He acknowledges their ordinariness, their earlier kindness, even their concern - however m isguided - about his choices. This nuance invites the reader to grapple with the uncomfortable reality that ext reme actions can emerge from love distorted by fear, d isinformation, and social pressure. It also underscores the role of third-party instigators, whose influence and coaching magnify fami lial anxieties into acts of

From a b roader human rights perspective, 4536 Days in Captivity raises urgent questions about the ba lance between protecting individuals from perceived harm and respecting their autonomy. It cha llenges the idea that “family matters” should be immune from legal scrutiny when they involve deprivation of liberty. It also highlights the dangers of conflating theological disag reement with moral or menta l unfitness.

For readers unfamiliar with Japan’s rel ig ious landscape, the book serves as a va luable primer on the Unification Church’s contested posit ion, the cultura l stigma attached to “new religions”, and the ways in which public fears can be mobil ized to justify rights violations. For those concerned with freedom of belief, it is a sobering reminder that such freedoms are only as secure as the willingness of institutions- and communities- to defend them consistently, even for unpopular minorit ies.

In the end, Goto frames h is surviva l not in terms of stubbornness alone but of purpose: the conviction that faith, once freely chosen, should be defended as a matter of persona l d ignity. His testimony is offered not only to recount what happened to h im but to stand w ith “those who are facing lonely and d ifficult battles in si lence.”

4536 Days in Captivity is thus more than memoir. It is a legal document in narrative form, a case study in psychological resilience, and an ethica l challenge to societies that permit the erosion of rights in the name of protection. It invites empathy w ithout demanding agreement on theology, and it leaves t he reader with a lasting unease about how easily ordinary life can be turned into a prison when fea r is given license over love.

Battle for Survival-4536 Days in Captivity has been published in Wash ington DC by The Washington Times Globa l Media Group, 2025.

Text: Knut Holdhus, editor

Featured image above: The English version of Toru Cato’s new book: Battle for Survival - 4536 Days in Captivity. Photo: FFWPU

Related to faith -breaking in apartment prison: Japan Following the Way of China

Also related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Media Stereotypes and Misinformation Challenged

Also related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Media Criticized for Stereotyping Minorities

Also related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Aher the N-Word: Is “Cult” Next Term to Be Banned?

Also related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Japan’s Dissolution Case Echoes China’s Playbook

And also related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: “Lavvyers Lying and Shaming Japan” for 50 Years

More, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Lawfare: State Uses Legal System in War on Faith

Also related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Media/Legal Expert: Communism Behind Persecution

And more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Militant Lavvyers Dictate Government Policy

And more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Media Helping Terrorist Reach His Goal

Related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Kishida Administration Giving in to Terrorism

And more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: 72 Religious Freedom NGOs Denouncing Japan

Yet more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Japanese Communists’ Final War

Still more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Political and Social Activism behind Oppression

And yet more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Opposition Inciting Regime to Excessive Steps

And still more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Journalist Reveals Ugly Lehwing Conspiracy

And even more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Gingrich: Kishida Joining Communist Campaign

Yet more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: The 3 Enemies of Religious Liberty

Still more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Lawyer Exposes Dirty Leftwing Plot

And yet more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Inhuman Government-Supported Mass Deprogramming

And still more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Bias: No Right to Respond for Religious Minority

And even more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Collusion to Rob Minority of Its Rights

Yet more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: State and Media Creating “Today’s Non-Citizens”

Still more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Japan Criticized for Glaring Rights Violations

And yet more, related to faith-breaking in apartment prison: Two European Scholars Warning Japan

Previous Next « Yonhap: Repeated Allegations… Japan: New Book On Legal An … »